A few rules were applied in making these choices. The single had to be released on vinyl in either the USA or UK. If the B-side was different in one country, I went with the version from the country in which the artist was resident at the time of the release. Promo or canceled releases are prohibited.
As far as the subjectivity of the choices, this is a list of my favorite singles, not favorite songs. Hence [#3] may be a better song than [#1] but based on my singles critera [#1] wins out. The criteria for a great single include
(a) the song must be instantly recognizable within two seconds
(b) the introduction must have that "wow" factor
(c) the quicker the tempo the better
(d) generally the run time should be less than three minutes (obviously [#3] and [#100] are massive exceptions
(e) the production must be either extravagant[#8] or bare bones [#9]
(f) clever lyrics are more important than the actual meaning of the words. Again, this is about what makes a great single, not necessarily a great song
(g) as my interest begins with the British Invasion, nothing pre-Beatles is included
Extra points for odd instrumentation such as glockenspiel, tubular bells, saxophone, tympani, strings, harpsichord. Additional extra points for lovely melody, vocal harmonies, and general "hookiness".
Songs further down the list may be lacking in one or more of these areas but have enough of the right stuff to earn their spot. So without further ado, here is Mister Pleasant's top 100 singles list.
Rank | A-Side | B-Side | Artist | Year |
1 | Lady Madonna | The Inner Light | The Beatles | 1968 |
2 | I Can See For Miles | Mary Anne With The Shaky Hands | The Who | 1967 |
3 | Hey Jude | Revolution | The Beatles | 1968 |
4 | Fire Brigade | Walk Upon The Water | Move | 1968 |
5 | Tonight | Hard To Get Over A Heartbreak | Raspberries | 1973 |
6 | Instant Karma | Who Has Seen the Wind? | John Lennon | 1970 |
7 | Waterloo Sunset | Two Sisters | Kinks | 1967 |
8 | Born To Run | Meeting Across the River | Bruce Springsteen | 1975 |
9 | Honky Tonk Women | You Can't Always Get What You Want | Rolling Stones | 1969 |
10 | This Town Ain't Big Enough for the Both of Us | Barbecutie | Sparks | 1974 |
10 | Itchycoo Park | I’m Only Dreaming | Small Faces | 1967 |
11 | Friday on My Mind | Made My Bed, Gonna Lie in It | Easybeats | 1966 |
12 | Desiree | I've Got Something on My Mind | Left Banke | 1967 |
12 | Accidents Will Happen | Sunday's Best | Elvis Costello | 1979 |
13 | Strawberry Fields Forever | Penny Lane | The Beatles | 1967 |
14 | Starry Eyes | Paint Her Face | The Records | 1979 |
15 | Do Ya | No Time | The Move | 1972 |
16 | Talkin' About The Good Times | Walking Through My Dreams | The Pretty Things | 1968 |
17 | Pictures of Lily | Doctor Doctor | The Who | 1967 |
18 | Bus Stop | Don't Run and Hide | Hollies | 1966 |
18 | Wichita Lineman | Back In The Race | Glen Campbell | 1968 |
19 | Brown Sugar | Bitch | Rolling Stones | 1971 |
20 | Wouldn´t It Be Nice | God Only Knows | Beach Boys | 1966 |
21 | Time Of The Season | Friends Of Mine | Zombies | 1968 |
22 | They Don't Know | You Broke My Heart in 17 Places | Tracey Ullman | 1984 |
23 | Rebel Rebel (US phased version) | Queen Bitch | David Bowie | 1974 |
24 | Junior's Farm | Sally G | Wings | 1974 |
25 | This Is The Story Of My Love (Baby) | Nixture | Wizzard | 1974 |
26 | Lady Friend | Old John Robertson | The Byrds | 1967 |
27 | Jumping Jack Flash | Child Of The Moon | Rolling Stones | 1968 |
28 | 7 and 7 Is | No. Fourteen | Love | 1967 |
29 | I Can't Let Go | I've Got a Way of My Own | Hollies | 1966 |
30 | Hello Goodbye | I Am The Walrus | The Beatles | 1967 |
31 | I'm On Fire | Did You See What Happened? | Dwight Twilley Band | 1975 |
32 | Something For the Girl with Everything | Marry Me | Sparks | 1974 |
33 | Overnight Sensation | Hands On You | Raspberries | 1974 |
34 | Message In A Bottle | Landlord | Police | 1979 |
35 | Be Stiff | Social Fools | Devo | 1978 |
36 | I Will Follow | Boy/Girl | U2 | 1980 |
37 | Sunny Afternoon | I'm Not Like Everybody Else | Kinks | 1966 |
38 | Pleasant Valley Sunday | Words | Monkees | 1967 |
39 | Pretty Ballerina | Lazy Day | Left Banke | 1966 |
40 | Autumn Almanac | David Watts | Kinks | 1967 |
41 | Everyone's Agreed That Everything Will Turn Out Fine | Next To Me | Stealers Wheel | 1973 |
42 | Whenever You're Ready | I Love You | Zombies | 1965 |
43 | A Whiter Shade Of Pale | Lime Street Blues | Procol Harum | 1967 |
44 | See My Baby Jive | Bend Over Beethoven | Wizzard | 1973 |
45 | All The Way From Memphis | Ballad of Mott The Hoople | Mott the Hoople | 1973 |
46 | Waterloo | Watch Out | Abba | 1974 |
47 | Eight Miles High | Why | The Byrds | 1966 |
48 | Goin' Back | Change Is Now | The Byrds | 1967 |
49 | If You Want My Love | Four Letter Word | Cheap Trick | 1982 |
50 | Mister Pleasant | Harry Rag | Kinks | 1967 |
51 | Carrie Anne | Signs That Will Never Change | Hollies | 1967 |
52 | Open My Eyes | Hello It's Me | Nazz | 1968 |
53 | Star | What More Could You Want | Stealers Wheel | 1973 |
54 | I'm A Boy | In The City | The Who | 1966 |
55 | Cecilia | The Only Living Boy In New York | Simon and Garfunkel | 1970 |
56 | Sail On Sailor | Only With You | Beach Boys | 1973 |
57 | Baby Blue | Flying | Badfinger | 1972 |
58 | Walking In the Rain | How Does It Feel? | The Ronettes | 1964 |
59 | Hand Me Down World | Runnin Down The Street | The Guess Who | 1970 |
60 | Dogs | Call Me Lightning | Who | 1968 |
61 | When I Grow Up (to Be a Man) | She Knows Me Too Well | Beach Boys | 1964 |
62 | Wedding Bell Blues | Lovin' Stew | Fifth Dimension | 1968 |
63 | Lola | Mindless Child of Motherhood | Kinks | 1970 |
64 | Valleri | Tapioca Tundra | Monkees | 1968 |
65 | Don't You Worry 'bout a Thing | Blame It On the Sun | Stevie Wonder | 1974 |
66 | Fight The Power (Part I) | Fight The Power (Part II) | Isley Brothers | 1975 |
67 | Blackberry Way | Something | The Move | 1968 |
68 | Message Of Love | Porcelain | Pretenders | 1981 |
69 | Mother and Child Reunion | Paranoia Blues | Paul Simon | 1972 |
70 | Paper Cup | Poor Side Of Town | Fifth Dimension | 1967 |
71 | Drive In Saturday | Round and Round | David Bowie | 1973 |
72 | Back on the Chain Gang | My City Was Gone | Pretenders | 1982 |
73 | The Kids Are Alright | The Ox | The Who | 1966 |
74 | Tell Her No | What More Can I Do? | Zombies | 1964 |
75 | Porpoise Song (Theme from Head) | As We Go Along | Monkees | 1968 |
76 | I Saw The Light | Marlene | Todd Rundgren | 1972 |
77 | Live and Let Die | I Lie Around | Wings | 1973 |
78 | Break Away | Celebrate The News | Beach Boys | 1969 |
79 | Albert Flasher | Broken | The Guess Who | 1971 |
80 | Care of Cell 44 | Beechwood Park | Zombies | 1967 |
81 | Hot Smoke and Sasafrass | Lonely | Bubble Puppy | 1968 |
82 | Sunrise | My Girl | Eric Carmen | 1976 |
83 | Superstition | You've Got It Bad Girl | Stevie Wonder | 1972 |
84 | Middle Of The Road | 2000 Miles | Pretenders | 1983 |
85 | Paperback Writer | Rain | The Beatles | 1966 |
86 | Jet | Let Me Roll It | Wings | 1973 |
87 | John I'm Only Dancing | Hang On To Yourself | David Bowie | 1972 |
88 | Ticket To Ride | Yes It Is | The Beatles | 1964 |
89 | Leave Me Alone | Takin' the Long Way Home | Peggy March | 1964 |
90 | Couldn't I Just Tell You | Couldn't I Just Tell You | Todd Rundgren | 1972 |
91 | She's Not There | You Make Me Feel Good | Zombies | 1964 |
92 | I Feel Fine | She's A Woman | The Beatles | 1964 |
93 | Talk of The Town | Cuban Slide | Pretenders | 1980 |
94 | All I Know | Mary Was an Only Child | Art Garfunkel | 1973 |
95 | No Matter What | Better Days | Badfinger | 1971 |
96 | You Got the Love | Rags to Rufus | Rufus | 1974 |
97 | Indication | How We Were Before | Zombies | 1966 |
98 | Join Together | Baby Don't You Do It | The Who | 1972 |
99 | Avenging Annie | So Fine (It's Frightening) | Andy Pratt | 1973 |
100 | MacArthur Park | Didn't We | Richard Harris | 1968 |
100 | Bridge Over Troubled Waters | Keep the Customer Satisfied | Simon and Garfunkel | 1970 |
30 comments:
I'm still on the list. thank you very much....Andy Pratt (Avenging Annie)
itsaboutmusic, myspace, youtube, itunes, rollingstone, wikipedia, amazon, allmusic, etc...
It's up! It's good!
I know where i'll be spending the spare moments of MY weekend!
Love the distinction between the best single and the best song!
Mucho mas comments to come, Senor Pleasant! :-)
A very cool list... lots to think about here!
PS: I'm not sure what's cooler -- the list itself or having an artist on the list comment about it!
"All The Way FROM Memphis"
Sorry, I'm on a crusade.
The Mott entry has been fixed - thanks Greg for pointing out my error.
Andy, it is wonderful to have you visiting here. Wait until you see my top 100 LPs list! Resolution is way-way up there. What happened with your videos on YouTube? I really miss that wonderful live performance of Treasure That Canary.
Alex and Who Am Us Anyway - always great to have you stop in. Looking forward to your future feedback.
Wa hahh hahh - Love that Sparks made the cut. And as a HUGE fan of The Records (I embarrassed Jude Cole by asking him to sign a copy of "Crashes"), cool to see "Starry Eyes." Fun List, color me Black Vinyl Impressed, I bow to you, Sir!
Great list! Not my list, but fun to read nevertheless, and I totally agree with your criteria. I am thrilled to see the Left Banke so well represented, a much neglected band IMO; I'm also happy to see that you've avoided the rock-snob prejudice against the Monkees.
Now I must go create my own list, with more girly things on it.
Tim - I could never omit Sparks from the list. You and I may be among the few professed Sparks fans in the US, but then I always enjoy being on the outside looking in. It is mega-cool that you met Jude Cole. I had forgotten that he had a short stint in The Records.
Thanks Holly. We each have our own lists and I am so looking forward to reading yours. Variety really is the spice of life. As for the Monkees, I get the feeling that their music has stood the test of time, and the old critical baloney about their musical abilities has pretty much been put to rest.
And the Left Banke - sigh - now there is the music as dreams are made on. It is a crime that their retrospective CD is out of print.
Woah ... tons of great Andy Pratt available for free listening over at his place!
Foist things foist, and so herewith the Whoamusanyway Embarrassing But True Ignorance Isn't Bliss List of 11 Songs he Never Would Have Heard But For the Pleasant Valley Sunday 104!!
I'm On Fire (i know the Bruuuuce song by this name but this must be diff)
Something For the Girl with Everything
Everyone's Agreed That Everything Will Turn Out Fine
See My Baby Jive
Star
Blackberry Way
Hot Smoke and Sasafrass
Sunrise
Leave Me Alone (i know a Heartless Bastards song by this name but this must be diff)
All I Know
You Got the Love
OK, off to iTunes now ... thanks, Mr. P!
More latah!
P.S. your html table looks great; i'm impressed with it to be honest -- way beyond my few html abilities!
A few random thoughts: Beatles, Beatles, Beatles plus two great Badfinger songs (why does everyone always forget "Baby Blue"?), two Simon & Garfunkel songs (plus one Simon and one Garfunkel).
But why only one John Lennon song (although it's a great one) and one Springsteen song (and not "Hungry Heart"/"Held Up Without a Gun")?
Songs I was happily surprised to see: Tracey Ullman's "They Don't Know," Dwight-Twilley Band's "I'm on Fire," "Jet."
Songs that made me scratch my head: the Wizzard tracks, some of the Byrds tracks.
I know it was probably difficult to cut the list down to only 100 (or 104) so I thank you for the time and effort it took to compile this!
Alex, what other John Lennon singles would you include in your Top 100 singles list?
Hey, why wasn't Crippled Inside released as a single?? Jeez.
Instant Karma truly is John's very best single, I think.
After that I think my Top 100 Singles would include (using Mr. P's criteria):
(1)
Whatever Gets You Through the Night
(2)
Mind Games
(3)
Happy Christmas War Is Over (i know: a guilty pleasure. But I'm a sucker for this kind of Xmas stuff).
And that would probably be it.
I love No. 9 Dream, Imagine & Jealous Guy as great songs, but they're not my idea of rock 'n roll singles?
OK, now i'm wavering on Imagine -- maybe i would include it.
But Give Peace a Chance and Power to the People, are great political theme songs more than singles i think.
Hungry Heart is my all-time favorite Springsteen song -- captures everything i love about him when he's at his best.
I'd personally rank it well ABOVE Born to Run, which while undeniably brilliant is a little too anthem-like, a little too stadium rock-like for my taste.
Nothing like great music to kick up a good discussion! I want to join in but first should mention that I added some Youtube links for the songs that Who Am Us listed. Dwight Twilley's I'm On Fire really should be heard in its original studio single version. Luckily the live version linked here is actually darn good, and has the added bonus of the lovely Susan Cowsill as a backup singer.
The version of Everyone's Agreed That Everything Will Turn Out Fine is the original 45 single, which is a completely different version that what is available on the album, and much much finer. Dig the Beatles-ish harmonies and the faux sitar raga section.
I can find no online audio for Peggy March's Leave Me Alone. It is an amazing early Randy Newman song, and the sixteen wunderkind sings it with emotion way beyond her years.
As for Art Garfunkel's first (and biggest) post-duo hit, it is possibly the loveliest Jimmy Webb song ever. It is a bit low on the list because it misses on several of my single's criteria, but that melody and Artie's vocal makes it impossible for me to omit it.
The singles of John Lennon were a tough choice for me. Same goes for George and Ringo. Frankly it is a travesty that I left Photograph off the list because I could have scored some points for both Mr. Starr and Mr. Harrison. The truth is I just forgot about it until now. It Don't Come Easy probably should be here too.
I never really saw George as a single's artist until after his career came down from the clouds. When We Was Fab and Blow Away bubbled up just under the top 100. In a couple of days I will post the next 20 or so that got bumped during compilation.
As for John, after Power To The People he became much more focused on albums, and the singles were just selling points for the LPs. That is not to say that Imagine is not one of the most magnificent and beautiful songs every recorded. It is, and when I get around to the top 100 song list it will surely be in the top 10. The fact that it was not released as a single in the UK was a major stumbling block to me for including it here.
#9 Dream also appears on the 100+ list. I liked the three singles from John's return to recording, especially Watching The Wheels, but listening to them even now I cannot divorce the awful memories of his murder from my head. Unfortunately that pall prevents me from being able to accurately gauge where they might fall on the list.
Agree re Watching the Wheels -- I love the song but tend to block it out of my mind. Really, absolutely everything from Double Fantasy is so hard to listen to for that very reason. Do you remember the great, funny, energetic and optimistic interview Lennon gave Rolling Stone to promote that album & which of course hit the news stands right after his murder? A double, no triple, whammy.
Alex, I am glad that you agreed about the inclusion of Tracey Ullman's great rendition of Kirsty MacColl's song. It scores points all over the place based on my criteria, but most of all it just gets to me in all the right ways.
Definitely Wizzard is an acquired taste. I can see where Roy's version of the Spector sound with globs of glam sprinkled about could rub someone the wrong way. Not me though.
I would be interested to know which Byrd's tracks you find to be odd choices. Or is it more what I did not list that has you scratching your head?
Yes I do remember that Lennon interview, Who Am Us Anyway. Even now I feel the sadness of those dark December days welling up inside me. A wonderful tonic is the post that Alex put up last year about the Imagine Peace Tower in Iceland. Go read - http://clicksandpops.blogspot.com/2009/10/imagine-in-iceland.html
I salute you, Mr. Pleasant. Thank you, thank you. #80's a huge fave of mine, and I'm loving that you included the Isleys. Oh, and all that delicious BB stuff... http://ssspunerisms.blogspot.com/2010/01/doughy-lumps-stomach-pumps-enemas-too.html
Hey Mr. P, thanks for the YouTube links!
You bet, Who Am Us Anyway. I am adding the links as I find time. Wish I could embed Lala links but at the moment it is a bit beyond me. And thanks for pointing out that Andy Pratt's site has music and videos, including the one I have been looking for.
Thanks Ssspune. I love #80 dearly too. I only wish it had been a hit. The Zombies might have hung on for a bit longer if it had been.
Re: Lennon -- I'd pick "Watching the Wheels" or even "(Just Like) Starting Over," but as singles, we'd have to take the B-side into account (and whatever you think of Yoko, that's gotta count against those singles).
"Happy Xmas (War is Over)" -- maybe. It's just not Christmas if I don't hear this.
But if I were to include two more Lennon singles, I'd definitely add "Mind Games," which is just the right mixture of dreamy and powerful.
If I only had one spot, I'd pick "Stand By Me" -- simple, eloquent, and beautifully sung. Ironically, when freed of the need be seen as a creative genius, he turns in one of his most heartfelt performances.
As for the Byrds, I guess I would put "Lady Friend" below "My Back Pages" or even "Turn Turn Turn."
Hey Alex, good to read your feedback. I just posted my list of the next 60 and sure enough Mind Games and Stand By Me are on the list, along with #9 Dream. I agree wholeheartedly about Stand By Me. It may be one of John's finest moments, and that is high praise from me because of the Beatles, I think he had the best pipes. McCartney has a great voice too but John gets the nod.
I find Rock 'n' Roll on my turntable more often than any Lennon LP other than Plastic Ono Band.
re: Lady Friend - it is definitely a personal preference on my part. Partly because the song was unknown to me until about five years ago, but mainly it just strikes a real chord inside me.
Yowza -- i didn't even realize that Stand by Me or anything else from that album WAS a single!
But i love the entire Rock 'n Roll album. For all the stories about what a mess the recording sessions were, I put my faith in Jim Keltner's eye witness account. I forget WHERE he said this, but in some interview he said the entire trip was an absolute gas and that Lennon was just so freaking witty & cracking wise that the hardest thing was not to keep laughing during a take. It's just great music, alcohol fueled or no!
The common wisdom (spread by John Lennon himself) is that the "lost weekend" period was just a series of pointless wasted days & nights. I'm sure there was a lot of that, but Lennon also recorded Walls & Bridges and Rock & Roll, produced and played on Nilsson's Pussy Cats, co-wrote and sang on Bowie's "Fame," co-wrote and played on several songs by Ringo, and hosted weekly jam sessions at a rented house on the beach in Santa Monica attended by many future inductees to the Rock 'n' Roll Hall of Fame.
Not too shabby for a "lost weekend."
Didn't Paul show up for one of those Santa Monica beach house jam sessions? I seem to remember hearing a hideous bootleg of the event.
But yes I would agree, John was quite productive during that period, regardless what he or others may have said.
And there was a second single planned from Rock 'n' Roll but Apple decided to pull it at the last minute. A lucky few have promo copies. It even has an official Apple record number -
P-1883 - for Ain't That a Shame b/w Slippin' and Slidin
Whooooooo could i-ma-gine ... that i never saw that Instant Karma video before? But no, I hadn't!
I'm still just cracking the surface of your top 104 ...
I read somewhere that Paul did show up for one of those Santa Monica jam sessions (and read somewhere else that Paul showed up at the recording studio where John was producing Pussycats).
There's a tape floating around on the internet called "A Toot and A Snore in '74" of a drunken jam session with John, Paul, and a bunch of other people. Quality isn't great, but the historical value is pretty high...
"A Toot and A Snore in '74" -- would love to see ...
I remember John saying Paul was over at the Dakota watching TV when SNL broadcast its Beatles reunion offer ("$3,0000 and you can pay Ringo less"). They actually called a cab and nearly went before deciding they were too tired.
Missed it by THAT much ...
Hey "I'm on Fire!" -- watching the video, it all comes back to me like a hot kisss at the end of a wet fist -- I always thought it was "You aint got no lover!" & of course being shall we say disorganized in 1975 had no idea whose record it was. :-)
That "almost" reunion on Saturday Night Live was as close as they/we ever got to seeing them together again. Sad but of course the music will live on forever.
I think you have the lyrics correct on I'm On Fire. That is certainly what I hear to this day. Nice chunky little power pop rocker by my home town boy Dwight.
Post a Comment